I prefer having a total comment count period (sort of like towerofanimus though I think their AC is a little lax) and mods having to reserve the right to ask for more activity if it's over like six tiny threads. I just feel like asking for a min comment count for each thread kind of penalizes characters who aren't chatty and are quick to the point. As well as having a min comment count doesn't ensure people won't just drop the thread once the AC requirement is reached, but no AC is perfect and squatters will always find a way around it.

Again, it's their right if that's the way they want to have AC (and it's a reasonable AC) and I have no sympathy from someone who should know what AC requirements are to begin with. But I'm just saying I can see her point on how min comment counts for each thread can kind of hinder people who are active but tend to wrap up threads a comment or two under the requirements.