'i don't like your interpretation and while it's not wrong you've taken the most literal, heavy handed approach and it's boring as fuck. you're limiting yourself from a lot of CR opportunities because you're so afraid to use your imagination and step outside of what's ~explicitly show in canon~. just because, idk for example, the character is never shown drinking alcohol because it's from a "kid show" (like avatar) that doesn't mean, given their temperament, career, history and other implications, it's very reasonable they could easily share a social drink as a CR hook. instead you squander this opportunity and fall back on ~well it's never shown~ reasons.

again, the interpretation isn't wrong but, on most days, it's awkward, boring as fuck and a disappointment compared to other people who play this character.'

giving them this crit is a probably moot point because they're extremely opinionated about this and act high and mighty when they ~fact check~ their canon.