You are part of a modteam running a game that's been around for a while. A group of newish players apps in and starts really pushing for changes to the game -- let's say the original game is a sex-positive fantasy game that sometimes has sexy events but is mostly gen, and they're complaining that players don't interact with the sex part enough, the game needs a smut AC implemented, there should be IC punishments for characters who aren't banging enough, and so on.

Your existing playerbase isn't really into most of these changes and the game has never been an outright sex game, but the outspoken new player faction is INSISTING that it needs to be the smutty fantasy sex game they seem to have thought they were joining. What do you do? Does your opinion change if a lot of the new blood is more active and engaged than the older playerbase, or if some (but not a majority) of your existing players like the idea of going more sex game-y?